Citizen 3d.:
Model and promote management of personal data and digital identity and protect student data privacy.
Have you ever read the terms of service on an app or web tool that you use in your classroom?
Of course not and you are not alone.NPR reported that less than one percent actually read the the terms of agreement. In and interview, an NPR correspondent discussed an experiment at the University of Connecticut where they had participants sign up to a fictional social media site. Part of the terms of agreement gave the social media site the permission to forward all material directly to the NSA. In addition, there was a very interesting agreement in which the site had naming rights of the first born. Ninety-eight percent did not notice this clause.1
What exactly are we (and asking our students) agreeing to when we use a digital tool in our classroom?
I took some time to investigate a few of common online tools to see what the terms are actually saying. I want to start by saying I now have a new appreciation for the terms of agreement; they are verbose and difficult to understand. No wonder less than one percent ever read them.
Remind 101
I started with Remind mostly because I have often had questions concerning student personal information with this tool. I was part of the integration of our latest SIS and LMS. There was a lot of concern for FERPA compliance whenever there was a resource that required our students to sign in. It seemed like with all the regulations we had to go through that Remind must not be meeting the standards I saw with our district
What I found, along with the other ressources, is that much of what they are doing is very extensive in protecting the company from any issues. It seems like the regulations that we have are significantly affecting companies like Remind to keep within legal and privacy rights. I was pleased to see commitments from Remind that all data such as names and phone numbers will stay private on Remind. There is even wording that assures that they will take reasonable steps to keep that data safe.2
One other portion of the terms stood out to me that did not seem as positive. There is an age limit in which a student must be over thirteen to be able to create an account. I did like that there were limitations on what a student under thirteen can do with remind but having an account is a whole other issue. Remind's terms mentions the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) where their must be consent for a student under thirteen. What they call verifiable consent falls on the responsibility of school to obtain this consent. Something that many school districts are most likely not doing.3
GSuite For Education
Google does not hide that it uses our information to sell ads. It is how Google is able to provide us Gmail, maps, Google drive, Google Docs, and a list of other services for what seem to be free. That is part of the terms of agreement for creating a public Google account, but what does that mean for our students? GSuite for Education does not fall under the same agreements as a public account does. This is why GSuite is not free. Districts pay for not having ads sold to their students and a higher level of privacy than a public account.4
TicToc vs. Flipgrid - Videos in the classroom
I have been hearing more and more about TicToc in the classroom. I was interested in looking at this resource because I have used Flipgrid to integrate videos in the classroom before, but Flipgrid is no where near to the level of interest and engagement of teens today. Therefore, a comparison of the privacy agreements seemed to make a lot of sense.
Flipgrid's privacy policy reminded me a lot of Remind's. Some of the same language with FERPA and COPPA where the student's data is protected. It is interesting how students under the age of thirteen are handled differently with Flipgrid. Flipgrid asserts that the owner of the grid (the teacher) is acting as the "parent agent" and meeting all requirements of COPPA.
After an extensive search of the terms within Tictok there are no mentions of students, FERPA, or COPPA. In fact the majority of what the privacy terms deals with is the intellectual property of others when a user creates a TicTok video. Tictok owns the data that is uploaded to it's site and what they can or can not do with it is not very clear in their privacy pages. 5
In February of 2019, TicTok's Chinese parent company ByteDance was fined 5.7 million for collecting personal information on children under thirteen. While it is important to mention that it is unclear if any of that data was sold or that there was a large editing of the company's privacy policy, it is still concerning. I also understand that during the time of Chinese backed TicTok's rise in popularity, there was a trade war between the US and China. TicTok is owned by ByteDance but the social media platform seems to have taken rise from a merger with a US company musical.ly. There are many concerns going on with TicTok. Some might be warranted while others can be exaggerated, but I would not feel comfortable asking my students to us this tool in the classroom.6
Lessons learned
It is understandable why only one percent of the population reads the terms of agreement and that might be more excusable when it is our public lives, but with education and student privacy being regulated by laws such as FERPA and COPPA, educators need to be aware of if the tool is lined up with what the district requires through their guidelines.
Online tools meant for student use do seem to work very hard to make sure that they provide the privacy we need for our students, but that does not give us a bye to not do our due diligence whether that be through the district or the classroom level teacher.
1. "https://www.npr.org/2016/08/23/491024846/do-you-read-terms-of-service-contracts-not-many-do-research-shows
3. https://help.remind.com/hc/en-us/articles/210737926-Parental-permission-to-use-Remind
4. https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en-US
5. https://www.tiktok.com/legal/privacy-policy?lang=en
6. https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/28/tech/tiktok-ftc-fine-children/index.html




This is very helpful thank you for taking the time to research this. I personally read terms and conditions more than the average person, but even still do so only occasionally. It's very helpful to have them distilled for us like this!
ReplyDeleteThis comment is from David Anderson - for some reason it's listing me as unknown... maybe I needed to read the terms for blogspot first! LOL
DeleteWOW! This was definitely eye opening. I always find myself second guessing the fact that I agreed, without reading the terms first, but who wants to do that?! I wonder what I'm actually agreeing to. In this digital world that our kids live in, I can't imagine all that they are agreeing to as well. It will definitely cause me to take a closer look-Tammy
ReplyDeleteThese are well researched and a benefit for our students.
ReplyDeleteConsistency comment only - TikTok (tictoc).
I typically skim over the terms and conditions, but like most do not take the time to really read them to see what I'm allowing. I appreciate that the online tools our students use have been doing well at safeguarding their privacy. If teachers choose to use other online sites, apps, or tools, I hope they will take the time to read the terms of use carefully to make sure they are safe, and make parents aware also. ~Staci Taylor
ReplyDeleteGreat Read! I never ever read the agreements! Because who has extra time, a law degree, and some super magnifying glasses to read the fine/tiny print? So happy that our school and district are taking measures to protect our kid's private information. I hadn't heard of Flibgrid. It's amazing how much social media keeps changing. Just when the parents are finally up to speed (Instagram) they move to snap chat, and now tic-tok. Thank you for the valuable information!
ReplyDelete